These comments are direct quotations from the Hansard
documents.
Year Round Access for Feeder Cattle
Mr. Howard Hilstrom
(Selkirk—Interlake, Canadian Alliance): Mr. Speaker, my question is
for the trade minister. For many years the Canadian Cattlemen's
Association has repeatedly called on the government to implement the
year-round access for American feeder cattle. In fact there was a key
resolution at the Canadian cattlemen's convention this summer.
The minister states that he listens and takes the advice of the Canadian
Cattlemen's Association. Will the government immediately implement
year-round access for American feeder cattle?
Hon. Pierre Pettigrew (Minister for International Trade, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, the government works very closely with the cattlemen, indeed on
any export permits that we grant. On imports we have been working with
them through the summer. We have brought in far more stringent regulations
precisely to help our cattlemen throughout this difficult summer. I intend
to continue discussing with them any changes to our policy. We have been
in close discussions with them.
Mr. Howard Hilstrom (Selkirk—Interlake, Canadian Alliance): Mr.
Speaker, the government is always saying that disease issues are the
reason we will not allow American cattle to come in here. The Canadian
cattlemen have stated unequivocally that disease issues are not a threat
to the Canadian cattle industry by having these feeder cattle come in.
American cattlemen see the year-round access for their feeder cattle as an
essential ingredient of a fair, equitable, integrated North American
cattle industry.
Why does the minister not realize that fair treatment of our American
neighbours will speed up the day that we have a fully open U.S. border for
our cattle?
Hon. Pierre Pettigrew (Minister for International Trade, Lib.): Mr.
Speaker, it has been a top priority for our government to maintain that
integrated North American economy and industry. We have been working with
the Americans very closely. We have made sure that the decisions we were
making would not threaten the integrated North American industry that
exists.
We are very confident that we will continue the good work of finishing the
job of opening the American border. This country is the first BSE affected
country to ever see an international border reopened to it and that is
because of the United States.
Hon. Lorne Nystrom (Regina—Qu'Appelle, NDP): Mr. Speaker, my
question is for the acting prime minister.
Unfortunately, as many as 650,000 cattle may have to be killed because of
restrictions on Canadian beef exports. Those cattle older than 30 months
cannot be exported and therefore have a lower market value because of the
lack of market in our country. These cattle are an acting time bomb for
the industry.
Could the acting prime minister tell the House what the government has
planned, to deal with a national cattle cull, and how this cull strategy
will be financed?
Hon. Don Boudria (Minister of State and Leader of the Government in the
House of Commons, Lib.): Mr. Speaker, the position that has just been
expressed by the hon. member is not even the position of the Canadian
Cattlemen's Association.
I will read from its press release of September 10, 2003, in which it says
that Canadians are proving their confidence in buying Canadian beef and
that this support would be jeopardized if the cattle industry were to
advocate a massive cull of cattle.
That is not the position of the industry at all and that is not what it
has said.
|